Paul Sullivan: ‘Madden’ movie looks bad, but a proposed show about the 1985 Bears might have some promise
- The recent 'Madden' movie, starring Nicolas Cage, received negative reviews for its portrayal of John Madden, failing to engage audiences.
- A new limited series based on the 1985 Chicago Bears is in development, aiming to capture the team's dynamic and connection with Chicago fans.
- Casting suggestions for the series include Michael Stuhlbarg as Mike Ditka and Austin Butler as Jim McMahon, promising an exciting ensemble. Read more
CHICAGO — Sports biopics are difficult to make for various reasons.
Finding the right actors to play famous sports figures is the hardest part, while replicating the game action is probably a close second.
Some work, and some fail miserably.
The producers got it right in the 1960s when they chose James Caan and Billy Dee Williams to play Chicago Bears running backs Brian Piccolo and Gale Sayers in the TV-movie “Brian’s Song,” an instant classic. Chadwick Boseman was perfect as Jackie Robinson in “42,” Robert DeNiro was the only choice for boxer Jake LaMotta in “Raging Bull,” and Brad Pitt was money as Oakland A’s general manager Billy Beane in “Moneyball.”
But Hollywood seemingly got it wrong when they picked Nicolas Cage to play John Madden in the recent Amazon release “Madden.” Cage, an iconic, Oscar-winning actor, donned prosthetics to try to resemble the overweight Madden, and the critics didn’t buy it.
A review in Variety said Cage was “buried under a jowly fatsuit that makes him look like Jiminy Glick playing John Candy,” adding that the movie “can feel like an extended ‘Saturday Night Live’ sketch played straight.”
“Madden” is streaming on Amazon, so you can judge for yourself. Consensus opinion is the movie fails to deliver on making Madden a character you really want to invest two hours in. But it also might be so bad that it’s fun to hate-watch, like Amazon’s fawning biopic on the first lady, “Melania.”
No harm, no foul. It’s just a movie, after all, and who cares if they accurately portray characters or situations we know well from watching sports on TV?
But another classic sports tale is in the works, and it should make Bears fans nervous. According to the Hollywood Reporter, producers are planning to adapt Richard Cohen’s book, “Monsters: The 1985 Chicago Bears and the Wild Heart of Football,” into “an event-limited series.”
The team that never goes away is coming back to a device near you.
“I want people in Chicago to watch this and feel like they are back there, and I want everyone who wasn’t there to understand why the rest of us have never shut up about it,” director Steve Pink told the Hollywood Reporter. “It should be loud, funny, emotional and alive. These were huge characters playing a brutal game in a great American city, and somehow the whole thing became a love story between a team and its town. That’s what I want onscreen.”
I’m super excited about the possibilities, but having “huge characters” in the plot doesn’t always translate to huge success with the project. The ’85 Bears obviously had a half-dozen or so intriguing characters whom I imagine would be the focus of the series and many others who would be part of the supporting cast.
While it’s impossible to cast the show without seeing the script, here are some actors we’d like to see involved.
The show’s protagonist would no doubt be coach Mike Ditka, whose battles with defensive coach Buddy Ryan were well chronicled, including the time they almost came to blows at halftime of the Miami Dolphins game. The feud of two giant-sized egos led to the memorable postgame scene from Super Bowl XX in which both were carried off on players’ shoulders.
Ditka was 46 in 1985, and though he’s a little older, actor Michael Stuhlbarg has the perfect mustache and face for the role and would be a fine choice to play Da Coach. For Ryan, who was 54 in ’85, you need a strong character actor who can portray an ornery guy from the South. There’s no one better for that than Woody Harrelson.
Quarterback Jim McMahon, the “punky QB” would likely be the player with the biggest role, along with William “The Refrigerator” Perry, the rookie defensive tackle who became a household name when Ditka inserted him into the backfield.
Many young actors would audition for the McMahon role, but I’d go with Austin Butler, assuming Butler can throw a spiral. Perry would be harder to cast because of his size, but Druski, the comedian and actor who recently hosted “Saturday Night Live,” could make it work.
Walter Payton would have a significant role because he’s Walter Payton. Obviously you’d need a big name to play “Sweetness,” and that calls for Michael B. Jordan, who once played a high school football star in “Friday Night Lights.” Receiver Willie Gault, who made the “Super Bowl Shuffle” project a reality, would be played by Jamie Foxx.
The supporting cast would include Zac Efron as Gary Fencik, John Cena as Dan Hampton, Jack Black as Steve “Mongo” McMichael and LaKeith Stanfield as Dennis “Silky D” McKinnon. Former NFL star Marshawn Lynch could cut his dreads and take the part of Otis Wilson, while only Daniel Kaluuya of “Get Out” fame has the eyes to play Mike Singletary.
As for Bears ownership, Dame Helen Mirren would be regal as Virginia McCaskey after starring as Queen Elizabeth II in “The Queen,” while “Succession” actor Kieran Culkin would play her son and team President Michael McCaskey.
A cameo role would be in order for NFL Commissioner Pete Rozelle, who fined McMahon for wearing an Adidas headband, leading to McMahon donning a “Rozelle” headband in the NFC championship game. The only actor who can play a buffoon like Rozelle with the necessary pomposity is Paul Giamatti.
With this solid cast in place, I’m already getting excited for “Monsters” to begin shooting.
So good luck, Hollywood, and let us know if you need any extras.
