1. Objective causes
Vietnam is a developing country with limited investment resources while the need for education is enormous; its complex terrain, frequent natural disasters, and dispersed population across many regions increase the cost of ensuring educational opportunities.
Population changes, migration, and rapid urbanization create localized pressures in cities and industrial zones.
Science and technology, especially artificial intelligence ( AI ), are developing at a pace that is outpacing the capacity of programs, teams, and evaluation systems in most countries.
At the same time, the sector is simultaneously carrying out its regular tasks, reorganizing its structure and network, and implementing a large volume of new policies, so delays in implementation are unavoidable.
The Party and the State have always considered education and training as a top national priority. (Illustration photo: VNA)
2. Subjective causes
Objective causes do exist, but subjective causes are the decisive factor. These can be broadly categorized into six groups, with the first being the root cause that governs the others.
The approach to educational development and management is primarily based on inputs and processes, not on outputs and impacts; it leans more towards "management" than "governance"; and the autonomy of educational institutions is not truly effective.
The view that "education is a top national priority" has been consistently affirmed, but its translation into action remains dominated by a long-standing approach: the state tightly controls input factors (staffing, quotas, conditions for opening new programs, facilities, documentation) and processes (procedures, approvals, reports), while output results (what learners actually achieve) and impact (how education contributes to productivity, innovation, and social cohesion) have not become the primary basis for resource allocation, evaluation, and accountability. The educational outcome chain can be envisioned as five stages: Input → Process → Output → Results → Impact; the current management system is "dense" in the first two stages and "thin" in the last three.
It is necessary to distinguish between two concepts that are often confused. Management primarily involves directing, guiding, and controlling hierarchical relationships, emphasizing compliance with regulations. Governance, on the other hand, is a system of institutions that define rights and responsibilities, decision-making mechanisms, power control, stakeholder participation, transparency, and accountability for results. Management answers the question "Have regulations been followed correctly?", while governance answers the question "Who has the right to decide what, to whom are they accountable, and what results have been achieved?". A modern education system needs both, but management must be placed within the framework of governance, not replaced by management alone. The Politburo 's Conclusion No. 91-KL/TW dated August 12, 2024, specifically calls for a strong shift from a "management" mindset to a "constructive governance" mindset. This requirement has not yet been fully reflected in institutions and practice. Specific examples include:
1) The management tools still heavily rely on pre-screening of input and procedural documentation. From procedures for opening new programs, setting targets, approving projects, to accreditation, inspection, and competition, the focus is often on "whether the conditions are met, the documentation is complete, and the process is correct," rather than "what the students have achieved." Quality accreditation in many places has become a "proof-making race"; supervision remains heavily reliant on paperwork, lacking a standardized system of outcome indicators such as the percentage of graduates finding suitable employment, the level of academic progress, and the impact of research. Budget allocation is still primarily based on input (number of staff, number of students, expenditure limits) instead of results or strategic orders. In secondary education, teachers and schools spend a lot of time on paperwork, reports, and competition records; these "favorable" percentages in reports become the goal, directly leading to a focus on achieving high scores.
2) The "management" mindset is still strongly evident in the language and structure of legal texts. According to the author's statistics, in the 2025 Higher Education Law (Law No. 125/2025/QH15), the word "management" appears 96 times, while the word "governance" appears only 6 times; and even where it appears, "governance" is often accompanied by the phrase "governance, management" or is only associated with the school council of private higher education institutions, which the law defines as "the governing body representing stakeholders" (Article 17). Legal language reflects the thinking of lawmakers: When the concept of governance has not been established as a complete institution (who decides the strategy, who supervises the managers, how stakeholders participate, to whom accountability is required), autonomy is easily misunderstood as "being allowed to do what the management agency permits."
Computer practice session at Phuc Hoa Junior High School ( Bac Ninh ). (Illustrative photo: VNA)
It should be noted that the Law has made significant progress: defining autonomy as the right to proactively make decisions coupled with accountability in academic, training, research, organizational, personnel, and financial matters (Article 3); affirming the guarantee of full and comprehensive autonomy for higher education institutions regardless of the level of financial autonomy; and allowing institutions to determine their own enrollment numbers and methods (Article 14). However, many aspects of autonomy are still implemented "according to the Minister's regulations" or awaiting further guidance, so the gap between rights on paper and rights in practice risks continuing to exist.
3) There is a tendency to shift the governance mechanism to an administrative management mechanism within educational institutions. According to the transitional provisions of the 2025 Higher Education Law, the school councils of public higher education institutions will cease operations (Article 46); only private institutions will maintain school councils. This policy aims to unify leadership and overcome the overlapping authority between the school council, the Party committee, and the board of directors, which researchers have pointed out as a reason for the slow progress in university autonomy.
However, it is also necessary to recognize that when the institutional representation of stakeholders no longer exists, if an alternative internal governance mechanism is not designed soon, clearly defining the leadership role of the Party committee from the operational role of the head of the institution, ensuring the genuine participation of faculty, students, businesses, the community, and mechanisms for monitoring and controlling power, then school governance is easily "bureaucratized," decisions are concentrated in the hands of the head of the institution, and accountability to society is narrowed to reporting to higher levels.
4) The autonomy of educational institutions remains largely superficial and inconsistent. In practice, autonomy was primarily understood as financial autonomy, meaning a reduction in allocated budgets and allowing schools to manage their own expenses; legal regulations on public investment, public assets, state budget, and bidding have not been adjusted accordingly, resulting in financial autonomy and autonomy in procurement and investment being constrained by multiple layers of procedures. In general and preschool education, the autonomy of schools is even narrower: Principals have virtually no authority to decide on teacher recruitment, personnel selection, or adjustments to expenditure structures; school educational plans still have to adhere to detailed guidelines and frameworks. In the context of network restructuring, many large-scale multi-level schools have been established, but the authority and management capacity of the heads of these schools have not been correspondingly enhanced.
5) The consequences of this approach are far-reaching. It creates an incentive for compliance rather than innovation; makes leaders hesitant to innovate for fear of "procedural errors" rather than fear of "failure to achieve results"; generates a large volume of paperwork, reports, and compliance costs; leaves the system lacking data on actual learner outcomes, making it difficult to detect weaknesses early (such as reading comprehension skills as indicated by PISA 2025); and blurs accountability, because when every important decision requires approval from superiors, no entity is fully responsible for the results.
International experience shows that successful education systems gradually shift towards a model of "the state creating standards and monitoring results; educational institutions being autonomous and accountable," with funding linked to results, and management based on standards and data. The 2026-2027 academic year has defined results as being measured by student progress, teachers' working conditions, school effectiveness, and human resource quality; the challenge is to translate this orientation into an operational mechanism.
Table 1: Comparison of two approaches in educational development and management
|
Aspect |
Input-based management - process |
Results-based management - impact |
|
Central question |
Are all the requirements met and is the process correct? |
What do learners gain, and what impact does it have? |
|
The role of the State |
Directly manage, approve, and pre-inspect. |
Establishing standards, placing orders, post-auditing, and monitoring results. |
|
The role of educational institutions |
To perform, to comply, to request permission |
Autonomy in decision-making, accountability. |
|
Resource allocation |
According to staffing levels, quotas, and quantities. |
Based on needs, order requirements, and results. |
|
Assessment tool |
Documents, evidence, performance ratios |
Output indicators, data, and independent evaluation. |
|
Explanation |
Report to superiors |
Transparency with students, society, and regulatory bodies. |
|
Organizational culture |
Compliance, safety, reluctance to innovate. |
Be creative, experiment with controlled methods, and learn from data. |
The hierarchical structure, coordination, and control mechanisms still have bottlenecks. The division of responsibilities between the central, provincial, commune, and educational institution levels within the two-tiered government model is not yet clearly defined; the workforce managing education at the commune level is still insufficient. In some localities, education has not received adequate priority in terms of land allocation, staffing, and budget. The legal system between the education sector and related sectors (finance, investment, human resources) lacks consistency; the mechanisms for preventing vested interests and corruption in recruitment, procurement, and accreditation are not strong enough.
Investment resources are insufficient and their utilization efficiency is low. Budget allocation is not truly based on actual needs, the scale of learners, and the conditions of each region; development investment and spending on research and higher education are still low compared to requirements. Investing in education is not just about increasing spending, but also about improving efficiency, publicly disclosing results, and ensuring that resources actually reach learners and teachers.
Policies regarding teachers and human resource management are not yet synchronized. The staffing and recruitment mechanisms remain rigid and slow to adapt to changes in scale; the remuneration system before the Law on Teachers came into effect was inadequate, reducing the attractiveness of the teaching profession in some sectors and regions. Teacher evaluation still tends to focus more on qualifications, seniority, and administrative records than on professional competence and the progress of students.
The current mechanisms for evaluation, examinations, and competition create "biased motivation." This is a direct cause of the obsession with achievements. When the percentage of excellent students, the graduation rate, and the number of awards are used as a basis for competition and ranking, those involved are motivated to manipulate the data. Assessments that primarily measure the ability to reproduce knowledge cannot encourage creativity; a college admissions system heavily reliant on scores increases the need for extra tutoring and exam pressure.
Forecasting capabilities, training-employment linkages, and social coordination remain weak. There is a lack of reliable labor market information systems and workforce demand forecasting; businesses lack the motivation and mechanisms to participate in substantive training. Coordination between families, schools, and society is ineffective in many areas; moral education tends to be "outsourced" to schools, while adult behavior, the living environment, and the media profoundly impact students' personalities. The pursuit of degrees and prestige continues to distort learning objectives.